Depression Symptoms Treatment

More than 20% of patients with major depression have not recovered after 2 years and, of those who do initially recover, 20% suffer a relapse 1 year later. Most studies have shown that 60% to 70% of patients respond to the first antidepressant used and a further 10% to 15% respond either to a second antidepressant or to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). About 15% of patients fail to recover even with multiple therapeutic trials and can be called treatment resistant. However, even these patients can be helped by supportive psychotherapy and lifestyle changes. The terms absolute and relative are used to describe treatment-resistant depression (TRD). Patients with absolute TRD have been correctly diagnosed, have received adequate treatment, but have failed to improve. Patients with relative TRD have not been adequately assessed, have not received adequate treatment, or have reached the limit of the expertise of their attending physicians.

Factors involved in treatment failure

Several questions should be considered when assessing patients with mood disorders who have not responded to treatment (Table 1).

Table 1. Diagnosing treatment-resistant depression

IS THE DIAGNOSIS CORRECT?

Rule out:

Obsessive compulsive disorder

Anxiety disorder

Posttraumatic stress disorder

Uncomplicated grief

CAN THE DEPRESSION BE SUBTYPED?

Consider:

Bipolar disorder

Delusional depression

Depression with obsessional features

Atypical depression with anxiety or panic

Postpartum depression

Double depression

Seasonal affective disorder

ARE THERE UNDERLYING PHYSICAL FACTORS?

Rule out:

Medical illnesses

Medical drugs

Drug abuse

ARE THERE UNDERLYING PSYCHOSOCIAL FACTORS?

Consider:

History of sexual abuse

Marital conflict

Social factors

IS THE CURRENT COURSE OF TREATMENT ADEQUATE?

Ensure:

Adequate dosage

Adequate length of time for treatment

Patient compliance

Minimal side effects, particularly sexual

Education of patient and family

Is the diagnosis correct? Several psychiatric illnesses present with depressive symptoms or with comorbid or secondary depression and are mistakenly diagnosed as a primary depression. These include obsessive compulsive disorder; panic disorder or generalized anxiety disorder with demoralization; posttraumatic stress disorder, particularly in adults who have been sexually abused as children; schizophrenic defect state with apathy; uncomplicated grief; and dementia, such as early Alzheimer’s disease with cognitive decline. Although anti-depressants might benefit some of these patients, the treatment approach to each of these disorders is quite different.

Can the depression be subtyped? For several subtypes of depression, a standard approach to treatment likely will be ineffective, and patients will appear treatment resistant. More information on these subtypes is available elsewhere.

Bipolar affective disorder, depressed phase: The depressed phase of bipolar disorder clinically resembles an episode of major depression. Introducing lithium or other anticycling drugs and avoiding drugs that might induce cycling becomes important. Rapid onset of symptoms, hypersomnia, a postpartum trigger, a history of manic or hypomanic episodes, or a positive family history are clues to bipolarity.

Delusional (psychotic) depression: A major depressive episode with psychotic features, such as mood-congruent delusions or auditory hallucinations, usually responds poorly to antidepressant monotherapy and requires an antipsychotic agent as well. Electroconvulsive therapy, however, is the treatment of choice.

Major depression with obsessional features: Major depression presenting clinically with obsessions and compulsions responds better to antidepressants that are strong inhibitors of the serotonin transport system, such as the tricyclic clomipramine or any of the selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs).

Atypical depression: Atypical depression is characterized by symptoms such as panic attacks, severe generalized anxiety, agoraphobia, or social phobia. Vegetative features are also atypical and include initial insomnia, increased appetite, hypersensitivity to rejection, and attention-seeking behaviours. Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (MAOIs) or the reversible inhibitors of monoamine oxidase A (RIMA) are probably the agents of choice.

Postpartum depression: About 80% of depressions that begin for the first time postpartum are bipolar. Postpartum depression often resists treatment. Psychosocial issues, such as bonding with the infant and the marital relationship, are very important and need to be addressed as part of the treatment plan. If the mother is hospitalized, physicians should consider admitting the infant once the mother has improved enough to show interest in and look after the baby, even if assistance from nursing staff is needed.

Double depression: Double depression, as the name suggests, is a major depression superimposed on chronic dysthymia. Chronic dysthymia usually requires psychotherapy and lifestyle changes, although pharmacotherapy can help. A major depression that responds to antidepressants might seem unresolved if the dysthymia continues untreated.

Seasonal affective disorder. In this disorder, probably a variant of bipolar disorder, patients suffer from a winter-onset depression for at least 2 consecutive years and have either a normal mood or mild hypomania during the summer. Seasonal affective disorder (SAD) is further characterized by carbohydrate craving, decreased energy, and increased need for sleep during the winter depressive phases. Some patients with SAD respond to traditional antidepressants or lithium, but the treatment that seems most effective is light therapy. Patients with variants of SAD, such as summer depression (and winter highs), sometimes respond to temperature manipulation rather than light.

Are there underlying physical factors?

Many physical diseases present with depressive symptoms or complicate depressive illness (Table 2). Some of these illnesses remain undetected for years and account for an apparent TRD. Normal thyroid function is particularly important; even mild or subclinical hypothyroidism can impair response to antidepressants. Hypothyroidism can be induced by lithium therapy, and many drugs, both medical and nonmedical, can cause depression or complicate treatment (Table 3).

Table 2. Medical illness that can cause or complicate depression

NEUROLOGIC

Parkinsonism

Multiple sclerosis

Myasthenia gravis

Stroke

Dementia (Alzheimer’s disease)

Lupus erythematosus affecting the CNS

ENDOCRINOLOGIC

Hypothyroidism

Hyperparathyroidism

Cushing’s disease

Addison’s disease

Diabetes

Menopause

NEOPLASTIC

Carcinoma of the head or the pancreas

Tumours of the CNS

Other neoplasms

RESPIRATORY

Chronic obstructive disease

CARDIOVASCULAR

Postmyocardial infarction

Hypertension

Congestive heart failure

INFECTIOUS

Postinfluenza syndrome

Human immunodeficiency virus

Lyme disease

OTHER

Nutritional deficiency

Anemia

Crohn’s disease

Irritable bowel syndrome

Chronic renal failure

Table 3. Drugs that can cause or complicate depression

ANTIHYPERTENSIVE AGENTS

Reserpine

Mcthyldopa

β-Blockers

ANTKONVULSANTS

Barbiturates

Phenytoin

H2 BLOCKERS

Cimetidine

Ranitidinc

ANTITUBERCULARS

Cycloserinc

ANESTHETICS

Halothane

TRANQUILIZERS

Benzodiazepines STEROIDS

NARCOTICS AND ANALGESICS

NONMEDICAL DRUGS

Alcohol

Cannabis

Amphetamines, cocaine (withdrawal)

Opiates

Are there underlying psychosocial factors?

Psychological and social factors, such as unresolved neurotic conflicts, a history of sexual abuse, current marital or work conflicts, unemployment, and poverty, can exacerbate mood disorders. Psychotherapy must be part of the treatment plan.

Is the current course of treatment adequate? The most frequent reason for patients not responding to treatment is inadequate use of antidepressants. Surveys have shown that two thirds of correctly diagnosed patients do not receive adequate treatment, even under specialist care. Inadequate dose is the most common reason for treatment failure. One third of patients do not respond to the first course of antidepressants; this proportion decreases with use of consecutive antidepressant trials.

The dose and duration of an antidepressant drug trial must be adequate. For most antidepressants, this means the maximum recommended daily dose for at least 3 to 5 weeks. Unpleasant side effects sometimes lead to noncompliance, and serum levels are sometimes subtherapeutic despite what seems to be an adequate dose. Other factors, such as alcohol or drug use or abuse, might affect serum levels.

If the antidepressant is a tricyclic (TCA), determining serum levels could be important for management; tests are readily available at most centres. Nortriptyline has a therapeutic range of 50 to 140 ng/mL (178 to 499 nmol/L). Other TCAs have a less precise range (about 150 to 200 ng/mL or 535 to 1070 nmol/L). Establishing serum levels can help to ensure compliance; ensure adequate absorption; and assist in dose adjustment for special groups such as the elderly or medically ill, when severe or unusual side effects are present or during apparent treatment failure. Serum levels unfortunately have not been established for other classes of antidepressants.

The most common causes of noncompliance are disabling or unpleasant side effects, particularly those that cause sexual dysfunction. Most side effects are transient; if persistent, they usually can be easily managed.

Many patients are reluctant to take antidepressants. They sometimes feel they are relying on a pharmacologic “crutch,” or that they are unworthy of receiving help. They fear addiction, worry about side effects, or could have

delusional beliefs about being poisoned.

Inadequate response to therapy can be iatrogenic. Lack of understanding of the biologic basis of depression, failure to educate patients and families, failure to conduct adequate treatment trials, or reluctance to prescribe the newer antidepressants, MAOIs, or ECT are factors.

Management of TRD

Major depression is best managed through a treatment algorithm. The more resistant to treatment a patient’s illness is, the further treatment proceeds through the steps. As each trial of therapy is deemed ineffective, diagnosis should be reviewed and physical and psychosocial factors reassessed before making a decision about the next step. Psychotherapy is an essential accompaniment to any form of somatic treatment. Supportive psychotherapy offers reassurance and time for patients to talk about their pain and also provides support

and education. Destructive lifestyles, guilt, low self-esteem, and anger are some of the issues that might need to be addressed. Some patients need to be referred for formal psychotherapy.

Strategies before changing antidepressants

Higher dose: For the new antidepressant compounds, most manufacturers recommend standard doses. If side effects are minimal, doses usually can be increased and tolerated well. Increasing the dose should be tried before adding other antidepressants or switching drugs. Lithium augmentation: For patients who have failed to respond to an adequate course of an antidepressant, lithium augmentation is the most reasonable next step (Table 4 summarizes augmentation strategies). About 30% to 50% of patients respond to this technique, and it seems to

work with all of the antidepressants (although less is known about how it works with the newer agents).7,8 Lithium, an antidepressant and mood stabilizer when used alone, appears to augment other drugs by enhancing postsynaptic receptor sensitivity.

To use this technique, the antidepressant should be continued at the current dose and lithium started at a dose of 300 mg three times a day. A positive response can occur in 5 to 12 days. If the response is positive, patients should continue to receive lithium for at least 6 months and in some cases for the duration of antidepressant therapy. Lithium levels should be monitored and kept within the therapeutic range of 0.6 to 1.0 mmol/L, and thyroid status should be closely followed.

Table 4. Summary of augmentation strategies

TRICYCLICS CAN BE AUGMENTED BY:

Lithium

Triiodothyronine

Monoamine oxidase inhibitors (selective combination)

Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors

Psychostimulants

L-tryptophan

SELECTIVE SEROTONIN REUPTAKE INHIBITORS AND OTHER NEW AGENTS CAN BE AUGMENTED BY:

Lithium

Triiodothyronine

Tricyclics

Psychostimulants

REVERSIBLE INHIBITORS OF MONOAMINE OXIDASE CAN BE AUGMENTED BY:

Lithium

Psychostimulants

Tricyclics (selectively)

MONOAMINE OXIDASE INHIBITORS CAN BE AUGMENTED BY:

Lithium

Tricyclics (selectively)

Triiodothyronine

Psychostimulants

Switching antidepressants. If lithium augmentation is ineffective, it should be discontinued and the antidepressant changed (Table 5). A lack of response to one of the newer agents in a class, such as the SSRIs, does not predict lack of response to others in that class. If the first drug used was a RIMA with only one drug in the class, the switch should be to an SSRI. If the original drug was an SSRI, a second SSRI, a RIMA, or other newer agents should be tried. If a TCA or MAOI was used first, the switch should also be to one of the new classes of antidepressants. The TCAs and MAOIs should be kept as third-line antidepressants. Evidence shows that response to an SSRI does not determine response to a TCA. One study has shown that 60.5% of patients who failed to respond to SSRI monotherapy responded when switched to a noradrenergic TCA.9 Most TCAs have both serotonergic and noradrenergic properties. Desipramine and nortriptyline are somewhat

more noradrenergic than the others. Venlafaxine, a new selective serotonin and noradrenaline reuptake inhibitor (SSNRI) might also be considered.

If atypical symptoms, such as panic attacks or anxiety, are present, an MAOI or RIMA should be considered after a suitable washout period for the previously used antidepressant (10 to 14 days for most antidepressants; up to 5 weeks for fluoxetine because of an active metabolite).

If the second antidepressant is not effective, lithium augmentation should be tried once more before the antidepressant is changed again.

Table 5. Antidepressants’ mode of action

INHIBITORS OF SEROTONIN AND NORADRENALINE TRANSPORT

Serotonergic tricyclic antidepressants (TCAs)

• Amitriptyline

• Imipramine

• Clomipramine

• Doxepin

• Trimipramine

Noradrenergic TCAs

• Nortriptyline

• Desipramine

Serotonergic heterocyclic

• Trazodone

Noradrenergic heterocyclics

• Maprotiline

• Amoxapine

(some dopamine-blocking activity)

• Venlafaxine

INHIBITORS OF SEROTONIN TRANSPORT (SRIs)

• Fluoxetine

• Fluvoxamine

• Sertraline

• Paroxetine

INHIBITOR OF SEROTONIN TRANSPORT AND 5-HYDROXYTRYPTAMINE POSTSYNAPTIC ANTAGONIST (SRI/5HT2)

• Nefazodone

MONOAMINE OXIDASE INHIBITORS (MAOIs)

• Phenelzine

• Tranylcypromine

REVERSIBLE INHIBITOR OF MONOAMINE OXIDASE A (RIMA)

• Moclobemide

Common strategies for treatment resistance.

Electroconvulsive therapy: An important and effective treatment for depression, ECT is effective in about 90% of cases of major depression. The success rate drops when it is used for drug-refractory cases. Using ECT depends on patient-related factors: it clearly is the treatment of choice for depression with psychomotor slowing, stupor, psychotic symptoms, or depression requiring rapid response because of suicidal risk or malnutrition. Use of ECT should be considered whenever therapeutic management is being reviewed and revised.

Triiodothyronine (T3) augmentation: Thyroid hormone potentiation of TCAs can be useful. The thyrotropin-releasing hormone stimulation test should be done first, if available and convenient, to rule out grade three (subclinical) hypothyroidism. If hypothyroidism is present, it should be treated with thyroid replacement therapy. If the patient is euthyroid, low doses of T3 (25 to 50 µg/d) can be given with the antidepressant for 10 to 14 days. Up to a third of depressed patients, particularly women, respond. Most experience with this approach has involved TCAs, and the effect on the SSRIs or other new agents is not well studied.

Tricyclic-fluoxetine combination: Some reports indicate that fluoxetine, when added to a TCA such as desipramine, can produce a robust and rapid response in many patients. This augmentation effect could be a result of increased TCA levels due to fluoxetine inhibition of the cytochrome P 450 system. Because fluoxetine can raise blood levels of TCAs, routine serum levels of TCAs are recommended. Other TCA-SSRI combinations can also be tried. All SSRIs, however, effect the cytochrome P 450 System by raising TCA levels.

Tricyclic-MAOI combination: Some evidence suggests that this combination is more effective than either drug used alone for some patients. Ideally both drugs should be started simultaneously or the MAOI added to a TCA regimen. The safest combination seems to be phenelzine with either amitriptyline or doxepin. Clomipramine, imipramine, and the new agents, such as fluoxetine, should be avoided. Give low doses initially and pay rigid attention to dietary restrictions.

The SSRI combinations: Although no literature supports the practice, clinical experience suggests that lower doses of two SSRIs together might work better than either alone.

Augmentation with L-tryptophan: L-tryptophan is the dietary precursor of brain serotonin. Reports confirm that L-tryptophan can enhance the antidepressant effect of MAOIs as well as TCAs and lithium. This might apply to the new antidepressant agents as well. The high doses required (more than 3 to 4 g/d) make this approach cumbersome because the tablets are quite large.

Psychostimulants: Dextroamphetamine, methylphenidate, and to a lesser degree magnesium pemoline all have moodelevating, psychoenergizing properties and have a place in the management of mood disorders. These drugs can be used alone or combined with antidepressants. Apathetic, elderly, and medically ill depressed patients often respond to psychostimulants when they cannot tolerate the side effects of antidepressants or a rapid response is necessary.

Psychostimulants are also useful for patients who do not respond to any antidepressant and are truly treatment resistant. Non-response to one psychostimulant does not predict non-response to another. There is no evidence of addiction or dose escalation although clearly this class of drugs needs to be prescribed cautiously and monitored carefully. Using psychostimulants is somewhat similar to prescribing analgesics for chronic pain conditions and can be justified considering the morbidity associated with major depression. Cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT): This therapy can be very useful for treating chronic depression, such as dysthymia, and can be helpful as an augmentation strategy in conjunction with pharmacotherapy for treatment-resistant patients. Several studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of CBT, a technique that family physicians can easily learn.

Less common approaches. Many less commonly used antidepressant therapies are supported by anecdotal evidence only. They include light therapy (non-SAD), high-dose TCA or MAOI therapy (only if serum levels can be monitored), intravenous clomipramine or maprotiline (allows for rapid perfusion, avoids first pass liver metabolism), bromocriptine, high-dose selegiline, and psychosurgery. Modern stereotaxic psychosurgical procedures offer symptom relief with minimal risk, and reports of large trials indicate that un to 60% of truly treatment-resistant patients either recover or are considerably improved.

Absolute treatment resistance. Very few patients show absolute treatment resistance. In specialized clinics, only about 7% of patients remain depressed after 1 year of extensive investigations and treatment. Extensive treatment involves many drug trials singly and in combination as well as one or more courses of ECT Patients with absolute TRD are older (mean age about 55), have been depressed longer, and usually have insoluble life problems.

Even patients with absolute TRD can be helped. Antidepressants often give some relief, and carefully prescribed psychostimulants can improve mood and psychoenergize.

Supportive psychotherapy and CBT can also be of benefit. Supportive psychotherapy helps depressed patients to carry on and CBT allows patients to view the world more positively. Regular exercise and reduction of alcohol consumption also help.

Prophylaxis

Discussing prevention of relapse or recurrence of major depression is beyond the scope of this paper but is clearly important. Long-term use of antidepressants is sometimes necessary particularly if patients have two or more episodes. Compliance becomes absolutely necessary but side effects often cause patients to stop taking medications. Tricyclics and, to a lesser degree, traditional MAOIs have many side effects because they act on the muscarinic, α1-adrenergic, and histamine H1 receptors. If an antidepressant is effective, the side effects can be managed.

The new antidepressants have become the agents of choice because they have fewer side effects. Sexual dysfunction is the most common reason for noncompliance and unfortunately is a relatively frequent problem with all antidepressants. Moclobemide and nefazodone seem to have the fewest sexual side effects.

For long-term therapy, doses that were effective for the acute episode should be continued. Clinical experience suggests a need for lifelong maintenance on antidepressants for patients older than 50 years at the time of first episode, for patients 40 years or older who have had two episodes, or for all patients with three or more episodes. If an antidepressant is discontinued, it should be withdrawn very gradually and signs of recurring depression monitored. Long-term use of lithium for prophylaxis of both bipolar disorder and major depression has also been shown to be very effective. There is a very high rate of attempted suicide among patients with major depression following lithium discontinuation.

Conclusion

Treatment-resistant depression is a relative term and depends on how far a physician is willing to go in treating a particular patient. Appropriate use of antidepressants can relieve symptoms in at least two thirds of cases. Drug combinations, ECT, and augmentation strategies can, if vigorously applied, reduce the proportion of patients truly treatment resistant to about 7%. Considering the morbidity and mortality associated with depression, a vigorous approach to therapy is worthwhile. Long-term maintenance, once success is achieved, is essential.